Make a Payment


To make a payment, select your insurance company below and call the telephone number listed. In most cases, you may also direct yourself to the company web site where you have the option to pay online.




Allied Insurance
Billing: 800-282-1446
Commercial: 866-322-3214



Auto Owners Insurance
Billing: 800-288-8740



Bristol West Insurance Group
Billing:888-888-0080





Foremost Insurance Group
Billing: 800-573-1187



Harleysville Insurance
Billing:800-433-6262



Safeco Insurance
Personal Billing: 800-332-3226

Commercial: 877-566-6001



Selective Insurance
Billing: 888-974-7400 x2100



United Christian Insurance
Billing: 888-974-7400


Get A Free Quote


Use our Insurance Quote Request forms to receive a free customized insurance quote:

Existing Customer Center


Make a Claim or File a Payment with us from right on the site!

Why Choose Buhl?


  • Independent Agency Advantage
  • Local Personalized Assistance
  • More Competitve Rates
  • Excellent Customer Service