File A Claim


To report a claim, select your insurance company below and call the telephone number listed.

To download a Workers Comp form, click here.


Accident Fund Insurance Company Of America
Billing: 877-563-4636
Claims: 800-888-0616



Allied Insurance
Billing: 800-282-1446
Claims: 800-282-1446



Auto Owners Insurance
Billing: 800-288-8740
Claims: 888-252-4626



Bristol West Insurance Group
Billing:888-888-0080
Claims: 800-274-7865



Citizens Insurance Company Of America
Billing: 800-573-1187
Claims: 800-628-0250



Foremost Insurance Group
Billing: 800-532-4221
Claims: 800-527-3907



Harleysville Insurance
Billing:800-433-6262
Claims: 800-892-8877



Safeco Insurance
Billing: 800-332-3226
Claims: 800-332-3226



Selective Insurance
Billing: 888-974-7400 x2100
Claims: 866-455-9969



United Christian Insurance
Billing: 800-234-6787
Claims: 800-234-6787


Get A Free Quote


Use our Insurance Quote Request forms to receive a free customized insurance quote:

Existing Customer Center


Make a Claim or File a Payment with us from right on the site!

Why Choose Buhl?


  • Independent Agency Advantage
  • Local Personalized Assistance
  • More Competitve Rates
  • Excellent Customer Service